Home
Program Description
News and Current Events
Homeland Security Focus Areas
Research Programs and Opportunities Conferences and Symposia
National University Consortium On Homeland Security
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
Related Sites
Program Development and Support Contact Us

























Homeland Security Focus Areas

Terrorism - General

Counterfeit Goods May Finance Global Terrorist Operations

International counterfeiting and law enforcement officials testified before the House Committee on International Relations on 17 July that as state-sponsored funding for terrorist organizations becomes scarce, groups like al Qaeda are turning toward intellectual property crimes to support their operations, according to media reports. Committee member commented that the testimony by Ronal Noble, Secretary General of Interpol and other witnesses represented the first time that law enforcement officials have drawn a line between black market sales and terrorism financing, according to the New York Times. Consumer goods counterfeiting, rife in major U.S. cities like New York, Los Angeles, and Miami, has an estimated yearly market value of $400 billion a year, costing American businesses approximately $200 billion a year, the New York Times and AP reported. Since the counterfeiting industry has little overhead and turns high profits, it is an easy way for terror organizations to raise money, Noble testified. Supporters of al Qaeda have been found in possession of large quantities of fake goods according to AP. "If you find one al Qaeda operative with it, it's like finding one roach in your house or one rat in your house. It should be enough to draw your attention to it," Noble said in his testimony.

ANALYSIS: While counterfeiting has long been tied to criminal activities, the congressional testimony reflected how homeland security officials are re-evaluating old crimes and the end beneficiaries, CNN noted. Now that the link has been established, anti-counterfeiting groups and industry leaders affected by counterfeiting are pushing the federal government to take steps to crackdown on intellectual property crimes. Some groups have proposed that the U.S. take the lead in encouraging international cooperation to crack down on counterfeiters, Fox News reported. Noble maintained that law enforcement agencies could make counterfeiting a high priority crime and do more to determine whose benefiting from the illegal sales, according to AP. Jack Valenti, president and CEO of the Motion Picture Association of America called for a federal response stating, "U.S. industry alone will never have the tools to penetrate these groups or to trace the nefarious paths to which those profits are put. Only governments have the tools necessary for this kind of investigation," GovExec reported.

Interpol: fake goods fund terror

WASHINGTON, July 16 (UPI) -- Groups like al-Qaida and Hezbollah have turned to trafficking in counterfeit consumer goods, a Interpol official will tell Congress.
"The link between organized crime groups and counterfeit goods is well established," states the written testimony of Ronald K. Noble, the secretary general of Interpol, in testimony to be presented Wednesday to the House Committee on International Relations.
"But Interpol is sounding the alarm that intellectual property crime is becoming the preferred method of funding for a number of terrorist groups."
But congressional officials told the New York Times Noble's testimony was the first by a senior law enforcement official to conclude emphatically, on a global basis, the trade in counterfeit consumer products financed terrorism.
Noble's appearance is the first time an Interpol secretary general has testified to a congressional panel. He is a former senior official at the Justice and Treasury departments.

Top Al Qaeda Agent in Iran, Official Says
Spokesman Abu Ghaith and several others are in custody, the source reports. U.S. is skeptical.
By Azadeh Moaveni
Times Staff Writer

July 15, 2003

TEHRAN - Iran has custody of several high-ranking Al Qaeda members, including spokesman Sulaiman abu Ghaith, a senior reformist official close to Iran's president said over the weekend. Diplomats in Tehran representing three countries also say that, based on their intelligence, Abu Ghaith is among those in custody.

The senior Iranian official declined to say how or when Abu Ghaith and the others had been apprehended or where they were being held. However, diplomats from another country indicated that Abu Ghaith, a native of Kuwait, had been in custody at least since June.

Diplomats said they believed the detainees were in Zahedan, the capital of Sistan-Baluchistan province, a region in eastern Iran populated by Sunni Muslims sympathetic to Al Qaeda.

U.S. officials were skeptical. "Everybody on the U.S. side has been saying, 'Not to our knowledge,' " said one U.S. official, speaking on condition of anonymity.

"We did have knowledge of a number of Al Qaeda people in Iran under some circumstance, rumors of them being taken into some kind of custody, the nature of which is unclear. Abu Ghaith is one of them."

Abu Ghaith has appeared on a number of video and audiotapes taking responsibility for Al Qaeda attacks, including a bombing at a Kenyan hotel last year that killed 16 people. Shortly after the Sept. 11 attacks, he appeared in a video and vowed that a "storm of airplanes" would continue to strike American targets until the U.S. ended its "crusade" against Afghanistan and Islam.

Western nations, including the U.S., have for months alleged that Al Qaeda members are in Iran. Tehran has said it has arrested a number of suspected Al Qaeda members, but it has kept the number of detainees and their identities tightly guarded.

What Iran intends to do with those in its custody is complicated by long-standing fractures among the different Iranian state institutions, such as the Intelligence Ministry, nominally under the control of reformist President Mohammad Khatami; the Revolutionary Guards, loyal to Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei; and the hard-line judiciary, controlled by powerful clerics.

The senior reformist official said Iran has been seeking to exchange information about those in custody in return for guarantees from Western governments to, in effect, shut down the Moujahedeen Khalq, an Iranian opposition group that wants to overthrow the Islamic regime in Tehran. The Iranians want the group's activities to be banned in Iraq, its longtime base of operations, as well as in Europe.

While Iran has been eager to appear cooperative in the war on terrorism and there are indications that it may be willing to extradite those in its custody, it appears highly unlikely they would be handed over directly to the United States.

'Axis of Evil'

Decades-old animosity with Washington, aggravated by President Bush's labeling Iran a member of an "axis of evil," has left Tehran reluctant to do any favors for the U.S. The hard-line Khamenei has refused to allow militants to be turned over to the United States, the senior Iranian official said. Reformists in the government, however, hope that cooperation over Al Qaeda can ease tensions with the West on a range of issues.

Further complicating any discussion of extraditions, the senior official said, is that the militants' countries of origin are hesitant to accept them.

"Say we return Abu Ghaith to Kuwait," said the official. "It could spark a revolution. Half of Kuwait listens to his tapes in the car, but the Kuwaitis would either have to execute him or turn him over to the U.S. It's awkward."

Kuwait has revoked Abu Ghaith's citizenship. Diplomats said Al Qaeda - and Abu Ghaith in particular - were among the subjects discussed when Kuwait's information minister visited Iran last month.

Iran has also had high-level contacts with Saudi Arabia recently. The head of Iran's judiciary, Ayatollah Mahmoud Hashemi Shahroudi, traveled to Saudi Arabia this month; during the visit, unprecedented for an Iranian judiciary chief, Shahroudi met with nearly all of the kingdom's leadership, diplomats said.

And the Saudi foreign minister, Prince Saud al Faisal, visited Tehran last month, diplomats said, to talk about Iran's Al Qaeda detainees, particularly any Saudis among them.

According to the senior Iranian official, optimism for a deal with Western governments was running high this spring, particularly before a suicide bombing in Saudi Arabia's capital, Riyadh, in May that killed nearly three dozen people and was blamed on Al Qaeda. Iranian hope for such a deal was bolstered when the U.S.-led coalition in Iraq rounded up and disarmed Moujahedeen Khalq members.

Iran's first step in any deal would have been to tell the West the identity of those it was holding; the hope on both sides was that this might have led to more substantive cooperation. The plan was scuppered at the last minute by a dispute among Iran's divided political factions over the terms of the bargain, the official said.

Ambitious Plan

Iran's ambitious agenda for dealing with the suspects - secure a deal over the Moujahedeen Khalq and win points with the West while staying in the good graces of Arab governments and public opinion - has created a set of conditions for any hand-over that one Western diplomat described as "following a classic Iranian pattern of bargaining so hard that the deal is lost."

"As always, we're losing out on these important chances," the senior Iranian official said, "because we can't negotiate with the United States directly, and our domestic problems mess things up."

How to deal with the Moujahedeen Khalq - also known by the initials MKO - may be a sticking point in any negotiations. Iranian officials have accused Washington of double standards in the war on terrorism, pressuring Iran to round up suspected Al Qaeda operatives but allowing the MKO - which is on the State Department's list of terrorist organizations - to retain a presence in Iraq.

Western officials have argued that Iran cannot equate the two organizations and that Tehran would be best served by cooperating rather than trying to drive a hard bargain.

"The MKO doesn't pose a global, imminent threat on the scale of Al Qaeda," said a Western diplomat in Tehran. "The Iranians accept this, but want to keep the moral high ground so they can link the two issues."

Some countries whose nationals may be among the detainees - Kuwait and Saudi Arabia - are U.S. allies. Tehran fears it cannot rely on assurances from such countries that U.S. officials will not be permitted to interrogate the fugitives and that intelligence relating to their time in Iran will be withheld from Washington. Tehran is concerned that the U.S. could use such information to accuse Iran of support for Al Qaeda.

Anti-U.S. Group in Iraq Claims Al Qaeda Link
Mon Jul 14, 4:25 AM ET

DUBAI (Reuters) - A group claiming links to the al Qaeda network has released a tape saying it, not Saddam Hussein loyalists, was behind attacks on U.S. forces, but offered no evidence to back up the claims.

"I swear by God no one from his (Saddam Hussein's) followers carried out any jihad (holy struggle) operations like he claims...they are a result of our brothers in jihad," said an unidentified voice on a video tape aired by Dubai-based Al Arabiya television Sunday night.

The tape bore none of the hallmarks of bin Laden and al Qaeda messages previously aired on Arab channels. It was not peppered with Koranic sayings and it mentioned the Western calendar before the Islamic calendar.

The voice on the tape, which sounded slowed down for disguise, warned of an attack in the days to come that would "break the back of America completely."

It was not clear if it was threatening an attack in Iraq, where 148,000 U.S. troops are stationed, or elsewhere.

The only image on the tape was a still of an unidentified white-bearded man in a turban. A spokesman told Reuters the channel had received an anonymous call asking it to collect the tape from a location in Baghdad.

The voice said the "Armed Islamic Movement for al Qaeda, the Falluja Branch," a previously unheard-of name, was behind the attacks and that its members were dispersed all over Iraq.

U.S. forces blame Saddam loyalists for most of the attacks that have killed more than 30 U.S. soldiers since May 1.

Earlier this month, an audio tape said to be made by Saddam urged Iraqis to fight the U.S.-British occupation.

The rhetoric on the tape conforms with Baath Party style used by loyalists of the deposed Iraqi president.

"I think this is by local groups who share al Qaeda's aims but I don't think it is issued by the group led by bin Laden," Egyptian expert on Islamist groups Dia Rashwan told al-Arabiya.

Calling on U.S. forces to leave Iraq, the taped voice warns "the end of America will be at the hands of Islam."

The voice prayed to God "to grant success to our brothers who are dispersed in Iraq's governorates and in the countries of the world, (especially) Sheikh Osama bin Laden and Mullah Omar" and stated the date as July 10, 2003.

Mullah Omar headed the Taliban government that harboured al Qaeda and was deposed by the U.S.-led war on Afghanistan.

"We don't have any way of proving or disproving what was said on that tape," a spokesman in Florida for the United States Central Command said.

July 11, 2003
Justice Department Seeking to Disallow Terrorist Interview
By PHILIP SHENON

WASHINGTON, July 10 - The Justice Department called on a federal appeals court today to reconsider an earlier ruling that would allow Zacarias Moussaoui to interview a captured member of Al Qaeda who had acknowledged that he was a crucial organizer of the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks.
In a series of filings, the department urged the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, in Richmond, Va., to rehearse arguments in the case and to block preparations for Mr. Moussaoui's interview of the accused terrorist, Ramzi bin al-Shibh, who is being held at a secret place outside the United States.
Mr. Moussaoui, a French citizen, is the only person now facing trial in the United States for conspiring in the terror attacks.
A lower-court judge in Alexandria, Va., ruled in January that Mr. Moussaoui and his court-appointed lawyers were entitled to question Mr. bin al-Shibh by video conference because it could produce information to bolster Mr. Moussaoui's defense.
Last month, a three-judge panel of the appeals court refused to block the lower-court order, saying the appeals court lacked the jurisdiction to intervene.
In its papers today, the Justice Department called on the appeals court to reconsider the department's arguments at a new hearing, either before the three-judge panel or before all 12 members of the court.
If the earlier ruling is not overturned, the department said, the government will be left with the "choice of disclosing highly classified information to an avowed Qaeda terrorist or having charges dismissed, evidence precluded or a damaging instruction given to the jury in the prosecution of that terrorist for his participation" in conspiracies that resulted in the attacks.

Kenya Charges Fifth Man in Terror Case

The Associated Press
Tuesday, July 8, 2003; 8:06 AM

NAIROBI, Kenya - A Kenyan court on Tuesday charged a fifth man in a terrorist attack in Mombasa that killed at least 10 Kenyans and three Israeli tourists in November.
Salmin Mohammed Khamis, 27, was charged with murder for the Nov. 28 attack on a hotel on Kenya's Indian Ocean coast. Four other Kenyan men were charged on June 24.
Khamis looked nervous as the court's clerk read out the charges and the names of 12 Kenyans and three Israelis killed in the attack.
Three of the four suspects are tied to a man suspected of being Fazul Abdullah Mohammed, an alleged al-Qaida operative and leading suspect in the November attack as well as the 1998 bombing of the U.S. Embassy in Nairobi.
Both attacks have been blamed on Osama bin Laden's al-Qaida network.
In the November attack, assailants attempted to shoot down a chartered Israeli jet with shoulder-fired missiles as it was taking off from Mombasa's airport. The missiles narrowly missed.
Within a few minutes of that attack, suicide bombers exploded a car packed with explosives outside a beachfront hotel 15 miles north of Mombasa, killing at least 10 Kenyans and three Israelis as well as the bombers. 

Suicide bombers kill at least 14 in Moscow

By Sarah Karush
Published July 6, 2003

MOSCOW - Two women strapped with explosives blew themselves up yesterday at the gates of a Moscow rock festival crowded with tens of thousands of fans, killing at least 14 persons and reviving fears that separatist rebels are bringing the Chechen war to the Russian capital.
The bombers, believed to be Chechen, were also killed. After the blasts, bodies lay splayed on the pavement, surrounded by pools of blood. Emergency response officers covered them with black plastic garbage bags.
Moscow city police spokesman Valery Gribakin said the explosions killed 14 persons - in addition to the two bombers - and wounded about 60. Russia's Channel One television reported that a 15th victim died in a hospital, but that could not immediately be confirmed.
Interior Minister Boris Gryzlov said suspicions pointed to Chechen rebels. News reports said a passport found at the bombing site identified a Chechen woman.
First Deputy Interior Minister Rashid Nurgaliyev said 13 sets of identification papers - including passports, train tickets and student identifications - were found at the blast sites and that most were matched with the dead.
The attack came hours after Russian President Vladimir Putin signed an order setting presidential elections in Chechnya for Oct. 5. The elections are the latest step in Mr. Putin's strategy of trying to bring a political resolution in the breakaway Caucasus republic even as fighting continues.
But rebel attacks have undercut Kremlin efforts to portray the situation in the war-shattered region as stabilizing.
Aslambek Maigov, the envoy of Chechen rebel leader Aslan Maskhadov, denied that Mr. Maskhadov was connected to the bombings. But the Chechen rebels are deeply factionalized, and only a small portion are believed to follow Mr. Maskhadov's direction.
Chechen rebels have shown an increased penchant for targeting civilians with suicide-bomb attacks during the past year. Fears of terrorism have been high in the Russian capital since the seizure in October of a Moscow theater by scores of Chechen militants, including women strapped with explosives and detonators.
The explosions occurred 10 minutes apart outside the Tushino airfield in suburban Moscow, where a crowd of as many as 40,000 was listening to a host of Russian rock bands at the one-day festival called "Krylya," or "Wings."
The rock festival is a popular summer event for Moscow's youth. The afternoon weather, cool and partly sunny, was ideal for attracting a large crowd.
Guards at the festival entrances were suspicious of the female bombers and prevented them from entering the grounds, Mr. Nurgaliyev said.
"When they approached the entrance, their agitation was visible. They tried to get in too fast and were turned away," he said.
The first bomber then triggered an explosives-packed belt, although it did not completely detonate. Police then directed people trying to go through the nearby exit to leave through another gate, and there the second bomb was detonated, said Rustam Abdulganiyev, 17, who had been inside the airfield.
Most of the casualties are believed to have been caused by the second blast, officials said.
Anxious relatives who heard reports about the explosions on Russian radio and television crowded the entrances but were barred from entering the airfield.
Many frightened parents tried to call their children's cell phones, but service was not working in the Tushino area.

FBI: Al Qaeda has blank Saudi passports

WASHINGTON (Reuters) --Osama bin Laden's al Qaeda network, whose operatives have used fraudulently obtained passports for international travel, has acquired stolen blank Saudi passports, the FBI said Wednesday.

In its weekly intelligence bulletin to local law enforcement officials, the FBI said the unissued Saudi passports are authentic and have key security features that allow them to pass routine examination.

"Numerous al Qaeda terrorists have also carried Saudi passports issued in the Holy Capital, another term for the city of Mecca," the FBI said.

It said past FBI intelligence bulletins have noted the use by Islamic extremists of fraudulent Pakistani passports and al Qaeda's use of altered or fraudulent Colombian identification cards and passports.

"Until recently, passports from Saudi Arabia have also been vulnerable to misuse ... because they were easily acquired under false pretense and were relatively easy to forge," the FBI said. "Nearly one-third of the Saudi passports confiscated from suspected terrorists and examined by U.S. authorities show signs of fraudulent issuance or alteration."

The FBI said new Saudi passports first issued in early 2002 incorporated features designed to hinder alteration. The blank passports al Qaeda acquired were from the new "E-series."

The FBI asked law enforcement authorities who encounter suspect travel documents, such as U.S. and foreign passports and visas, to contact immigration officials at the Department of Homeland Security.

Italian Daily: Bin Laden Spotted in Iran, Planning New Attacks

Milan daily Il Corriere della Sera reported on 25 June that a "highly confidential" report making the rounds in Italian intelligence circles indicates that fugitive al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden had been sighted in Tehran, Iran in late May. According to the paper, the report also warns that the terror organization is possibly planning attacks in Italy, Turkey, and Pakistan, and that two al Qaeda lieutenants traveling under the names Khalid Amin and Musa Jabir arrived in Rome in early June. According to the Il Corriere report, the dossier does not say what possible targets might be or what methods would be used, though it does say that the individuals have training in "operational espionage."

ANALYSIS: The article referenced the possibility that the information is coming from an "allied" country, rather than from Italy's own intelligence service, and there has been no pickup of the report in other European media. Iran does have an al Qaeda presence in the country - the Iranian government admitted on 27 May, in response to U.S. pressure, that it was holding a "handful" of suspected al Qaeda members, and Saudi officials have been in talks to extradite some Saudi nationals suspected of involvement in the Riyadh bombings in May - but no other open source has indicated that bin Laden himself was in Iran. The article's author, Fiorenza Sarzanini, writes often on terror-related subjects and has a history of reporting on supposedly secret documents and papers speculating on possible attacks by al Qaeda, Ansar al-Islam, Italy's own Red Brigades, and other terror groups.

CQ HOMELAND SECURITY - COURTS & JUSTICE
June 25, 2003 - 7:36 p.m.

Islamic Religious Groups Jockey for Prison Access As Concerns Over Inmate Terrorism Grow

By Amy Menefee, Special to CQ Homeland Security

"There is a big problem with extremism in the jails in this country."

That sentiment doesn't come from Attorney General John Ashcroft or the FBI, although it well could have. It came from a prisoner - a Muslim prisoner - whose letters from a federal penitentiary were obtained by CQ/Homeland Security on condition that the author not be identified.

More than 13,000 federal prisoners claim allegiance to some form of Islam. Until Sept. 11, 2001, few people cared much about their religious preferences or the prison chaplains who served them.

Now, they do.

Militant Muslim prison organizing has not only raised the ire of Shiite and moderate Sunni Muslim prisoners but caught the attention of U.S. counterterrorism officials, and now Congress, which will hold the first of a series of hearings Thursday.

Some Muslim organizations, however, have been concerned about militant Islamic organizing behind bars for a decade. The agents of influence are clerics from the Wahhabi branch of Islam, the faith officially sanctioned by the Saudi royal family and associated with Osama bin Laden.

"In these prisons it is hard to come across authentic Islamic books," wrote one prisoner two years ago, "because the Wahhabism dominates the prisons with their possenous [sic] books."

Wahhabism, also known as Salafi - the term "Wahhabi" is considered offensive by many members of the sect - dominates federal Muslim prison chaplaincies in the U.S., according to many sources.

Hedieh Mirahmadi, director of public affairs for the anti-extremist Islamic Supreme Council of America, says she's been fielding prisoner complaints like the one above for 10 years.

One prisoner asked the leader of a Muslim organization to raise "the issue of miseducation of Muslims in prisons and the right we have to be taught traditional Islamic doctrine."

Another prisoner complained that a fellow convict who was schooled in Wahhabi extremism was transferred, leaving the rest of the Muslim population vulnerable to Salafi/Wahhabi influence.

"That brother had lots of knowledge to keep the Salafis in check, now that he's gone it's gotten crazy!"

"Whoever gets there first," said Mirahmadi, "wins" the battle for Muslin hearts and minds. And Muslim extremists got to U.S. prisons first a long time ago, she says. There, some teach a hatred of the United States akin to that preached by Osama bin Laden.

Mirahmadi's organization, which represents itself as a purveyor of "classical" Islam, hopes to see more Sunni and Shiite chaplains adding "religious diversity" to the prisons.

In New York, four Shiite prisoners filed a lawsuit, now on appeal in district court, saying their rights had been violated by the state prison system. They complained that prison officials and Wahhabi chaplains had denied them access to literature and teaching in line with their beliefs.

In recent years, the only two organizations certifying Muslim clerics for federal prison service have been Wahhabi-related: the Graduate School of Islamic and Social Sciences (SISS) in Leesburg, Va., and the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA), based in Plainfield, Ind.

The SISS is still under investigation in connection with the 2002 Customs search for terrorist funding ties, dubbed Operation Green Quest. ISNA, which is affiliated with Hartford Seminary's training program for Muslim chaplains, will hold its sixth annual conference on Islam in U.S. prisons July 4 weekend in Dallas, Texas.

The Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) says other Muslim organizations are free to sponsor chaplains - they just haven't done it. But Mirahmadi said certifying chaplains isn't as simple as they say.

Wahhabist Web

The SISS and ISNA don't state a Wahhabi affiliation on their Web sites. But they are affiliated nonetheless, said Stephen Schwartz, senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, a nonprofit Washington-based terrorism research organization.

Schwartz will testify before the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Terrorism, Technology and Homeland Security on Thursday.

Schwartz, a Sunni Muslim, has published a guide to Muslim organizations operating in North America. He said "the court has been lax in its oversight" of these organizations.

"SISS represents an extremist ideology being taught in our prison system," said Schwartz, who suggested the BOP change its chaplain hiring process.

"We don't feel that this is a good policy for the security of the U.S."

A spokesman for SISS was not available for comment.

The ISNA is just trying to contribute to the American chaplaincy as it evolves, said Ingrid Mattson, who serves a dual role as director of Hartford Seminary's training program for Muslim chaplains and vice president of ISNA.

"The Muslim community hasn't developed criteria for who can be endorsed as a Muslim chaplain," Mattson said, adding that she hadn't heard of other organizations in the endorsing arena besides her own and SISS.

Muslim clerics aren't used to thinking of the chaplaincy as a separate profession, she said.

"We try to clarify that the role of a chaplain" is to help "people of all faiths," Mattson said.

"What I teach the chaplains is, their role is not to be an enforcer of a particular position within the Muslim community."

Islamic Communities

Though many have expressed concern about the role of the Graduate School of Islamic and Social Sciences and the Islamic Society of North America as the only organizations endorsing federal Muslim chaplains, the Bureau of Prisons says other groups just haven't applied to challenge them.

"Other national religious groups have the opportunity to serve as endorsers," said a BOP statement in response to repeated inquiries. "However, at this time, only two [ISNA and GSISS] have completed the appropriate documentation to serve in this role."

Because applicants name their own endorsers, those from other Muslim groups could have the same opportunity, the statement said.

"At the request of Islamic candidates, we requested general endorsement information from another organization on two occasions, but the documents were not returned," the BOP said.

This illustrates a responsibility that lies with Islamic organizations, said Paul Rogers, president of the American Correctional Chaplains' Association.

"It's an Islamic community issue," Rogers said. "There might be some political and religious infighting in the Muslim community."

But Mirahmadi said her experience has contradicted BOP's stance.

"It's not as simple as filling out a form," said Mirahmadi, who has worked trying to place Sunni and Shiite chaplains.

"To be able to prove that you're being discriminated against is very difficult," she added.

A Civil Action

While the Muslim community irons out the meaning of a chaplain, some prisoners on the inside say they're facing discrimination.

Schwartz's foundation has filed an amicus brief on behalf of four Shiite prisoners in the New York state prison system.

The inmates, whose suit is on appeal and scheduled for oral arguments July 14, are seeking prayer services and literature congruent with their beliefs.

Earlier, the court had said prison policies were sufficient to accommodate all Muslims and had told the state prison system to watch for discrimination against the Shi'a.

The results were not satisfactory, said the prisoners' attorney, Andrew Kent, because the differences between the sects can't be underestimated.

"You can't compare this to Baptist and Lutheran," Kent said, likening the doctrinal divide more to that between Catholics and Protestants.

In fact, Schwartz said, Wahhabis often call Shiites members of a "Jewish conspiracy."

Kent said he doesn't foresee constitutional obstacles to granting Shiite prisoners their own services.

"I don't think it's quite as tricky as the prison officials want you to think," Kent said. "The prison system has not worked with us constructively on this. They've just been challenging us in court."

That, however, is on the state level - where selection and monitoring of chaplains is anything but uniform. In the federal system, a selection process is already in place that includes criminal background checks, educational requirements, ministry experience and endorsement from a recognized religious body.

Threat Matrix

Meanwhile, the FBI is interested in the prison chaplaincy as a possible recruiting platform for militant extremists. The bureau is developing a handbook on spotting terrorist recruitment efforts in prisons, said spokesman John Iannarelli.

Members of Congress have also expressed interest in a review of federal prison policies.

Sen. Charles E. Schumer, D-N.Y., urged an "immediate investigation" in a March letter to the Justice Department's inspector general.

"It is disturbing that organizations with possible terrorist connections and religious teachings contrary to American pluralistic values hold the sole responsibility for Islamic instruction in our federal prisons," Schumer wrote.

The Justice Department would "neither confirm nor deny" that an inquiry is under way.

More recently, Rep. Howard Coble, R-N.C., chairman of the House Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime, Terrorism and Homeland Security, addressed an inquiry to Bureau of Prisons Director Harley Lappin with a response requested by June 25.

"What standards does the BOP use to ensure that prisons are not being used to spread Islamic extremism and terrorism?" Coble asked. "What additional tools does the BOP need to prevent these persons from entering the prisons?"

The Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Terrorism, Technology and Homeland Security, chaired by Arizona Sen. Jon Kyl, will begin to address these issues Thursday in a hearing titled "Growing Wahhabi Influence in the United States."

Another hearing, titled "Recruitment of Terrorists in Prison," is yet unscheduled but may come in early July, committee aides say.

From the "Congressional Quarterly Homeland Security Daily," 24 June:

Launch Looms for Banks’ Anti-Terrorism Requirements
A new broad-spectrum, post-9/11 vaccine designed to inoculate the U.S. financial system against terrorist money-launderers takes effect July 1. Thereafter, all federally-insured banks, savings associations, credit unions, bank holding companies, subsidiaries of bank holding companies and branches of foreign banks are obligated to serve as informants and investigators for the Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Center (FINCEN). The law known as the USA Patriot Act expanded their responsibility to report “known or suspected” crimes by insiders or clients, according to a FINCEN announcement, along with illegal, unusual or unreasonable transactions above certain limits; attempts to evade bank secrecy regulations; and any intrusions into their computer systems. The firms must submit a Suspicious Activity Report within 30 days of detecting untoward conduct, but can take up to 60 days if they need more time to identify the suspects. Get the details at www.fincen.gov. -Jim McGee

Terrorism Spending Capped by Senate Appropriators
For months, senior agency officials in the Homeland Security and Justice departments have urged Congress to spend more on terrorism. But last Friday, those executives got yet another firm reminder that funding remains tight on Capitol Hill. A sharply divided Senate Appropriations Committee nailed in place the 302(b) allocations for the fiscal year 2004 budget, thereby setting the legal ceilings for the appropriations subcommittees which produce individual spending bills. When the committee came to Homeland Security and Justice, those figures were markedly lower than the allocations approved earlier by the House. For the Subcommittee on Homeland Security, the full Appropriations Committee authorized $890 million less than the House allocation of $29.4 billion. For the Commerce, Justice and State Appropriations Subcommittee, the panel picked a figure that is $900 million less than the House total of $37.9 billion. -Jim McGee

Air Marshals Packing Heat on Canada Flights
U.S. air marshals can now carry guns on flights into Canada thanks to a top-secret federal cabinet order in Ottawa exempting them from provisions of Canada’s strict gun laws. The order was passed May 29, CanWest News Service reported on Sunday. Canadian officials refused to comment on the decision. Officials would not say whether the armed marshals are restricted to U.S. carriers or also are flying on Air Canada and other Canadian airlines. The Transportation Security Administration has thousands of armed air marshals who fly on commercial flights every day, but refuses to discuss when and where they are deployed. -Jeremy Torobin

Biotech Pioneer Gets DOD Contract for Terror Defense
The Defense Department has entered into a four-year $23 million contract with IGEN International Inc., for products that can test for biological agents, the company announced Monday. The Gaithersburg, Md.-based company will develop the products, based on its existing technology called Origen, for DOD’s Joint Program Executive Office for Chemical and Biological Defense, which will use them for field and lab tests. The Pentagon set up the joint executive office in April to consolidate similar offices in the different services. IGEN said it will receive $7 million over the next year. Founder and CEO Samuel Wohlstadter (who also founded biotech giant Amgen) and his family own about 20 percent of IGEN. Surging company revenues are credited in part to growing sales of its homeland security testing products, which are used by the Food and Drug Administration, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Department of Agriculture. -David Clarke

Feds Seeding Rebirth of Ground Zero Transit Crushed on 9/11
The Transportation Department is sending $50 million to the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey to help rebuild subway lines and stations destroyed in the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks. The initial grant will fund environmental and preliminary engineering work for the Fulton Street Transit Center, designed to connect several Lower Manhattan transit lines. In February 2003, New York Republican Governor George E. Pataki identified nine potential projects to be funded from the $4.55 billion appropriated by Congress to rebuild and enhance transportation projects in Lower Manhattan. The Fulton Street Transit Center project was one of them. - Anjali Cordeiro

Bradley U. Student Declared ‘Enemy Combatant’
The federal government has put a Qatari national arrested in Illinois in late 2001 into the category of an “enemy combatant,” transferring him to the custody of the Defense Department, the Associated Press reported Monday. Investigators believe Ali Saleh Kahla al Marri, 38, who came to the United States on a student visa, used fake names to open bank accounts which he used to funnel money to help al Qaeda operatives settle in the United States. Al Marri is named as an unindicted co-conspirator in the indictment of Zacarias Moussaoui, who faces Sept. 11-related charges in federal court in Virginia. In May, a federal grand jury indicted al Marri on seven counts of lying to the FBI, using false names to open bank accounts, and credit card fraud. At the time of his arrest, al Marri was studying computer science at Bradley University in Peoria, Ill. As an enemy combatant, al Marri will be tried by a military tribunal rather than in the civilian criminal justice system. -Chris Logan

Senate FAA Authorization Detailed Here
The Senate’s fiscal 2004 Federal Aviation Administration reauthorization bill, like the House version, includes provisions designed to boost security for air travelers. A House-Senate conference will be held to iron out the differences between the two bills. -Caitlin Harrington

French probe links to terrorist activity
By Verena Von Derschau
Published June 23, 2003

PARIS - French judges yesterday placed 17 suspects under investigation for links to terrorism in a crackdown on an Iranian exile group that triggered a hunger strike in Washington and protests in several European capitals.
The suspects, who are one step short of being charged, include Maryam Rajavi, a co-leader of the Mujahideen Khalq and wife of the group's chief, judicial officials said on the condition of anonymity.
Police on Tuesday raided the Mujahideen Khalq's offices near Paris. Authorities initially detained more than 150 members of the group, which the United States and European Union have linked to terrorism. Mrs. Rajavi and 10 others remain in custody.
The raids set off protests by the group's supporters in Washington, Paris, Rome, London and elsewhere, with several setting themselves on fire. A woman in Paris died from her burns.
The supporters in Washington yesterday entered the sixth day of a hunger strike outside the French Embassy. They said the health of some protesters was deteriorating.
"France has shamefully continued its unlawful and politically motivated detention of Mrs. Maryam Rajavi along with ... members of Iranian resistance," the group said in a statement.
"Iranian-Americans call upon the democratic governments of the world to stand by the millions of Iranians and their resistance movement against the terrorist regime of Iran and its dirty plots in France."
A statement issued in Paris urged supporters to remain calm.
"We appeal to aggrieved compatriots to refrain from self-immolation and only pursue their demands through peaceful sit-ins," it said.
The 17 persons placed under investigation were questioned at a Paris courthouse late Saturday and early yesterday. Riot police and other security forces surrounded the building and blocked access to a nearby subway station and the adjacent Sainte-Chapelle church, a tourist attraction.
Authorities questioned the suspects about their activities with the Mujahideen Khalq, which opposes the Muslim clerical government in Iran. The group has been based in France since shortly after the 1979 Islamic Revolution that toppled the Iranian monarchy.
Those put under investigation were being probed for "association of criminals in relation with a terrorist enterprise" and "financing of a terrorist enterprise," officials said.

The Washington Times

U.S. citizen secretly pleads guilty to scouting hit sites for al Qaeda
By Frank J. Murray
Published June 20, 2003

An al Qaeda sleeper agent "wrapped in his cloak of American citizenship" has secretly pleaded guilty to aiding Osama bin Laden by scouting out bridges and railroads for destruction in New York and Washington, Attorney General John Ashcroft said yesterday.
"We have taken another American-based al Qaeda operative off the streets, who appeared to be a hard-working American trucker, but secretly scouted terrorist strikes that could have killed many of his fellow citizens," the attorney general said.
He refused to confirm that the charges involved a plot to destroy the 120-year-old Brooklyn Bridge but pointedly added that he was not denying it, either.
Mr. Ashcroft said Iyman Faris, 34, alias Mohammad Rauf, pleaded guilty May 1 to living "a secret double life" in which he worked on figuring out how to plunge a particular New York bridge into the river by cutting its suspension cables with "gas cutters" and obtaining "torque tools" to derail trains in the Washington area.
Faris, a Kashmir native who emigrated to Columbus, Ohio, and drove fuel trucks with access to U.S. airports, faces a maximum of 20 years in prison and a $500,000 fine when he is sentenced Aug. 1.
"I think it's pretty clear from the plea agreement itself that he certainly was not a lone terrorist. A person who goes to see Osama bin Laden, who takes direction from other high-ranking al Qaeda operatives, who reports to high-ranking al Qaeda operatives his activities, is not a solo operative in the sense of being a lone terrorist," the attorney general said.
"While we think we are disabling al Qaeda, we do not believe that al Qaeda is disabled," Mr. Ashcroft said in announcing the guilty plea while refusing to say when or where Faris was arrested, or whether other conspirators were seized.
The two-count plea-bargain unsealed yesterday showed that Faris admitted giving material support to al Qaeda and to joining a conspiracy to commit new acts of terror. The plea document describes numerous, more serious offenses with which he was not charged, which may indicate he has become a cooperating witness.
When asked whether Faris or his family had entered the Witness Protection Program, Mr. Ashcroft said, "Not to my knowledge."
Papers in the case were unsealed yesterday in Alexandria federal court by U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema, who also presides over the case of Zacarias Moussaoui, the only person yet charged with direct participation in the September 11 attacks.
The plea document said Faris canceled plans for the bridge attack because security was too tight and its suspension cables did not seem vulnerable. Early this year, he dispatched a coded message that said, "The weather is too hot."
Faris emigrated to the United States in May 1994 and became a naturalized citizen in December 1999, soon after he became eligible, the attorney general said.
In addition to acting as a foot soldier who scouted targets, Faris admitted he bought 2,000 sleeping bags for al Qaeda terrorists and researched use of ultralight airplanes for the group.
He also said he disguised himself to visit a travel agent and obtain extensions on airline tickets for six al Qaeda agents' flights to Yemen, and delivered money and cell phones for the terrorist group.
Mr. Ashcroft would not disclose how far the U.S. plots went beyond theoretical stages.
"Let us just say that we believe that the plea reflects that he was involved in a meaningful way in a terrorist plot, and that the kind of activity that he is reflected as having is essential to the potential success of such a plot. So we consider him to have been a meaningful participant in a real situation," he said.
The Justice Department would not disclose any aspect of the investigation including how or when FBI agents learned of his plot.
However, a June 23 Newsweek article reported the substance of the charges announced yesterday and said the information was provided by Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, accused of being the mastermind in the September 11 attack and once a "most wanted" terrorist in the Manila-based plot to bomb as many as 12 airliners over the Pacific.
Newsweek said Faris paid a $200 speeding fine in May but had not been seen in weeks at his tiny, white frame house in Columbus. It is likely, however, that Faris was in custody before May 1.
Mr. Ashcroft conceded that recent speculation, including some of his own, about a plot to simultaneously blow up U.S. gas stations grew from Faris' use of "gas stations" as a code word for the acetylene torch to be used for cutting the bridge cables but had not confirmed it.
"That's an assumption. If you write that, you write that at your own peril, not me. But you know, that's the only gas cutter I know of," Mr. Ashcroft said yesterday.
When asked about secrecy in this case and 15 others that remain sealed, Mr. Ashcroft said the Faris developments were kept secret to avoid "impairing very important interests."
He gave no hint what interests were involved nor would he discuss whether any other recent arrests were related to the Faris case.

June 19, 2003
False Terrorism Tips to F.B.I. Uproot the Lives of Suspects
By MICHAEL MOSS

One evening in late April, the F.B.I. chief in Indiana, Thomas V. Fuentes, went to a crowded basement in an Evansville mosque to ask for help in the fight against terrorism. Some 100 Muslims listened politely.
Then the wife of a local restaurateur spoke up to tell him what had happened the last time agents came calling, shortly after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks. On a tip, her husband, Tarek Albasti, and eight other men were rounded up, shackled, paraded in front of a newspaper photographer and jailed for a week. The tip turned out to be false.
But four of the men were then listed in a national crime registry as having been accused of terrorism, even though they were never charged, as the F.B.I. later conceded. The branding prevented them from flying, renting apartments and landing jobs.
"People were crying as she describes this," Mr. Fuentes recalled. "And at the end, she says, `My husband was released, and in 19 months nobody has ever said, I'm sorry about what happened.' "
Mr. Fuentes did more than apologize. Last week, at his behest, a federal judge ordered that the men's names be erased from all federal crime records.
The unusual public move to clear the Evansville men of suspicion comes after several terrorism cases collapsed because they were based on tips that proved wrong.
Federal agents, facing intense pressure to avoid another terrorist attack, have acted on information from tipsters with questionable backgrounds and motives, touching off needless scares and upending the lives of innocent suspects.
After a wave of criticism, Bush administration officials have been revising their policies for handling terrorist suspects. On Tuesday, President Bush issued guidelines restricting racial profiling in investigations to "narrow" circumstances linked to stopping potential attacks.
In a report earlier this month, the Justice Department's inspector general found that in the months after the Sept. 11 attacks, many illegal immigrants with no connection to terrorism were detained under harsh conditions.
Federal officials vowed to take corrective steps, including a more careful assessment of anonymous tips. However, they defended their strategy of running most terrorist tips to the ground, calling it critical to thwarting another attack.
But court records and interviews with officials and witnesses show that even seemingly plausible information from tipsters who eagerly came forward to identify themselves has led to misguided investigations.
In Michigan, Mohamed Alajji, a trucker born in Yemen, was jailed for seven days last December before agents interviewed his accuser, who turned out to be making false claims against him to press a family feud.
In Texas, Esshassah Fouad, a student from Morocco, was detained after his former wife accused him of plotting terrorism. She was sentenced to a year in prison for making a false charge. But Mr. Fouad was hit anyway with immigration charges, despite his pleas that he had missed school, violating his visa, because he was in jail.
The federal and state authorities in Detroit exhaustively investigated accusations by a tipster, Gussan Abraham Jarrar, against seven United States citizens, who he said had formed a terrorist gang called "Whatever It Takes." All of the accusations proved false, and Mr. Jarrar, who had a long record of previous arrests, eventually pleaded guilty to providing false information.
Attorney General John Ashcroft told a Congressional panel on June 5 that he would continue to detain people for as long as it took to ensure that they had no terrorist ties. "Obviously in an ideal world we would like to be able to have cleared people instantly," Mr. Ashcroft said.
But critics warn that law enforcement officials, facing pressure to act fast in running down tips, can too easily leave innocent people mired in suspicion, and alienate possible future sources of good information.
Sorting fact from fiction has always been a challenge for crime fighters dealing with informers, whether they are investigating bank robberies or drug deals. With most tips shrouded in secrecy, there is too little information available from the government to know whether problems with tipsters have increased in the fight against terrorism.
But after the Sept. 11 attacks came a scramble to find any remaining terrorists, and President Bush put out a nationwide call for eyes and ears to be alert.
With thousands of tips coming in every week, the F.B.I. was hard pressed in those early days merely to take in the information, officials said, especially since Justice Department orders were that no plausible tip was to be ignored.
"At one time, when information came to us, a lot of times based on experience the investigator would say, `Nah, this is not something we will follow through on,' " said Bill Carter, an F.B.I. spokesman in Washington. But after the Sept. 11 attacks, he said, "The director has stated that no counterterrorism lead will go uncovered."
At an F.B.I academy meeting last year, in which strategies for gathering intelligence were discussed, one participant warned that officials were overlooking the effect that pursuing suspects has had on Muslim and other targeted groups.
"I made myself the skunk at this lawn party by saying I didn't think that rounding up people whose names wouldn't be released, and whose civil rights are violated, would allow law enforcement officials to implement an effective plan," said Clark McCauley, a professor of psychology at Bryn Mawr College.
Some early tips fell apart in highly public ways, as when a security guard named Ronald Ferry claimed to have found a ground-to-air radio in a certain room in a hotel across from the World Trade Center. The guest who was occupying that room, Abdallah Higazy, was jailed for nearly a month on suspicion that he had helped guide the hijackers who crashed airplanes into the twin towers. Mr. Ferry's falsehood was uncovered when an airplane pilot, who has not been publicly identified, came forward to claim the radio.
A lawsuit Mr. Higazy has brought against Mr. Ferry and the F.B.I. says the agents who took the tip failed to press Mr. Ferry for a sworn statement, to subject him to a lie detector, or to interview a second guard who helped search the room, said Robert S. Dunn, a lawyer for Mr. Higazy.
"They just took his word and ran with it," said Mr. Dunn. F.B.I. officials in New York declined to comment, citing the pending litigation.
The hope of avoiding deportation by cooperating with the government has led some people to reach out to the F.B.I.
The federal authorities say that Hoda Elsaidy, an Egyptian living in California, told them last summer that her husband was plotting to bomb the federal government's Defense Language Institute in Monterey, and that one terrorist cell member had already been paid $90,000 by overseas conspirators.
An F.B.I. agent, according to court records, said the bureau, in turn, promised to help Mrs. Elsaidy resolve a lapsed resident's visa. But after investigating, the authorities concluded that she had made up the story, and she has been charged with providing false information. She has denied the charge.
Her husband, Hany El Nady, was cleared of the terrorist accusation but was imprisoned for other immigration violations and has agreed to leave the country, along with their four children.
Sometimes only the F.B.I gets hurt. John Habenstein, a New Jersey man who presented himself as an expert on Middle Eastern affairs, sent agents scurrying on a sweeping and time-consuming search of a ship for weapons of mass destruction. He later admitted that he had lied in order to promote himself as terrorism expert for hire. But when suspects are involved, officials are having a hard time deciding when to close cases and clear names.
In the Evansville case, the F.B.I. defended its decision to detain the nine men and blamed local jailers for the incident in which the men were photographed. The agent in charge, Thomas Van Wormer, said 40 agents investigated them for a week, "and at the end we sat down and said these people shouldn't be held."
As for this week's move to expunge their names from criminal records, he said: "They were innocent. Not fixing this would be wrong."
But in other cases, officials say they it has been difficult to clear away all suspicion. The case of Mr. Alajji, the Michigan trucker, illustrates the limbo into which terrorist suspects can be thrust.
When investigators got a tip last December that he was plotting a bomb attack, F.B.I. agents tracked him down, searched his rig and interviewed friends and associates. The United States attorney in Detroit had him charged with Social Security fraud, using the tip and other information from the agents to argue that he should be held without bail.
But one thing investigators had not done was talk to the tipster, who named Mr. Alajji using a hot line for terrorist tips. When agents did so nine days later - pressed by a skeptical judge - the bombing plot went up in smoke. "He recanted," said Eric M. Straus, the assistant United States attorney who handled the case.
Mr. Alajji had divorced the tipster's sister, and she was fighting to regain custody of their children, according to people on both sides of the family feud. Prosecutors decided not to press charges against the tipster.
Matters only got worse for the federal team when the judge threw out the fraud charge as unsubstantiated, dismissing the prosecutor with a stinging reference to the George Orwell's work on "totalitarian government."
Mr. Alajji was set free, but says the ordeal wrecked his business and compelled him to return to Yemen.
"I did not feel safe in the U.S.," Mr. Alajji said in a telephone interview. "I felt I was being watched all the time, and the prosecutors decided that the file would remain open and I could be arrested at any time."
Mr. Straus says there was other information beyond the false bombing tip that cast suspicion on Mr. Alajji. As for the swift jailing, Mr. Straus said he and other prosecutors simply had no choice, given the magnitude of the threat. "With terrorism you do not have the luxury of sometimes waiting to figure out if the guy is truly a terrorist."

Morocco blames bombings on international terrorists
Spokesman: Investigation will prove link to foreign group

RABAT, Morocco (CNN) --The Moroccan government said Tuesday that an international terrorist network was behind the bombings that killed 31 people as well as 12 suicide bombers May 16 in Casablanca.
"The attacks' international connections are getting clear," government spokesman Nabil Ben Abdallah said in comments quoted by the state-run news network Maghreb Arabe Presse [MAP].
"We are convinced there is a foreign hand in the matter, not that of a country, but rather of an international terrorist network," the agency quoted him as saying. "The probe will end up proving it more precisely."
The Moroccan government said 91 people have been brought to court in connection with the near-simultaneous explosions at a Spanish social club, a hotel, a Jewish cemetery, a Jewish community center and the Belgian consulate.
More than 100 people were wounded in the attacks.
Ben Abdallah said Moroccan Islamist movements, "through their ideas and a somewhat moralizing attitude, have contributed in spreading extremist ideas."
He called on Islamic organizations to respect democracy, keeping religion and politics separate.
"[The Islamists] must take a clear stand in the Moroccan democratic landscape and reject any confusion between religion, shared by all Moroccans, and the political, which is open to everyone."
On Monday, Moroccan Prime Minister Driss Jettou had said his country is not facing any threat of "Islamic extremism" and that attacks like those in Casablanca "can happen anywhere," according to MAP.
An official of the Islamist Justice and Development Party, which has been gaining popularity in Morocco, was among those arrested on suspicion of having prior knowledge of the attacks, Moroccan officials said.
Ben Abdallah said the party can become "like any other if it decides to play the national democratic game. It is not the case today ... The party has extremely unclear and equivocal attitudes on a number of issues. Personally, I don't think they adhere in the country's democratic map."
The attacks targeted "a project for a modern, democratic society" that Morocco has been developing, Ben Abdallah said. "The Moroccan society should not be misjudged. It is deeply yearning for modernity and democratization."

Journalist's sentence reduced
In a separate development Tuesday, Morocco's court of appeals reduced by one year the sentence of a journalist sent to prison for slandering King Mohammed VI and offending "Morocco's territorial integrity and sacred values," according to the state-run news agency.
Ali Lamrabet will have to spend three years in prison instead of four, according to MAP. The court upheld the ban of his satirical publications, the French-language "Demain" and the Arabic-language "Doumane."
The World Association of Newspapers and the World Editors Forum, which represent 18,000 publications in 100 countries, have urged the government to release Lamrabet, saying his imprisonment "is a clear breach of his right to freedom of expression."
Lamrabet may appeal to the supreme court.

Bombing in Tel Aviv raised vexing questions
Los Angeles Times

June 17, 2003

JERUSALEM -- The result of the odyssey that brought two suicide bombers to a beachfront bar in Tel Aviv was not unusual: They died. And so did three of their 58 victims.

But otherwise, the story of the attack six weeks ago breaks with the familiar narrative of suicide bombings in Israel. The bombers were not Palestinians from the dusty towns or seething refugee camps of the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

The two were Britons of Pakistani descent, radicalized in the Islamic extremist milieu in Britain that has been a breeding ground for Al Qaeda. They became the first foreigners to commit a suicide attack here since the start of the intifada in 2000.

It is not clear who gave the orders to blow up Mike's Place, a coastal hangout for English speakers, on April 30. The identity of the masterminds has become the subject of a politically charged dispute.

Israeli officials said Monday that their security forces are "examining suspicions" that the attack teamed the Palestinian militant group Hamas with Al Qaeda recruiters who groomed the bombers. Because Al Qaeda activity in Israel has been limited, such an alliance would be worrisome.

"It shows a very ominous trend," said Raanan Gissin, a spokesman for Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. "This is the first time that we have found evidence that Hamas was working to recruit suicide bombers through Al Qaeda."

But Israeli officials offered little proof. Hamas usually takes responsibility for its attacks; it has not made any claim on the Tel Aviv bombing. Hamas leaders Monday denied any link to Al Qaeda and accused Israel of trying to discredit them at a key moment in a military and diplomatic struggle with the Sharon government.

"Of course the world today is fighting Al Qaeda," said Ismail Abu Shanab, a Hamas leader in the Gaza Strip. "And Al Qaeda has a different struggle from the Palestinian struggle. . . . And Israel wins if she makes links between the two issues."

Israeli officials insist Al Qaeda's offensive converged with Hamas' intelligence-gathering infrastructure and its need for operatives with European passports who can move more easily through Israeli checkpoints.

But Omar Bakri, an extremist Syrian cleric based in London who knew one of the bombers since boyhood, said profound "sectarian differences" make cooperation between Hamas and Al Qaeda unlikely.

Copyright © 2003, Chicago Tribune

Hunt in N. Iraq For al Qaeda Is Hit and Miss
Troops Rely on Sketchy Sources
By Sharon Waxman
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, June 16, 2003; Page A18

KIRKUK, Iraq, June 15 -- The word came at 11:15 a.m. -- al Qaeda suspect in the southeast sector of the city.
At the Kirkuk air base, headquarters for the 2nd Battalion, 503rd Infantry, U.S. Army Lt. Col. Dominic Caraccilo weighed his options.
Orders had come from Central Command to move this weekend against anyone suspected of posing a threat to U.S. forces, an operation across Iraq called Desert Scorpion. Saturday night, Caraccilo's men had picked up 13 former military and intelligence officials and members of deposed president Saddam Hussein's Baath Party, detaining them at the air base.
But in northern Iraq -- particularly near the Iranian border, where an al Qaeda-linked guerrilla group called Ansar al-Islam had been based until the war -- U.S. forces are particularly concerned with tracking down suspected al Qaeda operatives. The effort has so far proved frustrating.
On Thursday, U.S. soldiers raided a home being used as a mosque in a Kirkuk neighborhood and arrested 74 people who were subsequently described by U.S. Central Command as al Qaeda sympathizers. In fact, the men, aged 18 to 60, were questioned for a couple of hours and released. "They weren't al Qaeda sympathizers," said Army Capt. Trish Cawdrey, charged with military intelligence in Kirkuk.
The men said they had gathered for a religious meeting, and the raid had turned up a single book about Osama bin Laden's life and philosophies, one commonly available in any Iraqi bookstore.
"The ideas in the book were not of a kinetic nature," Cawdrey said. "There was no linkage to al Qaeda or terrorism. Great Satan is not part of the book. . . . It's been reported incorrectly, even on the military channel."
An Army officer who declined to give his name said that in this often tense, multi-ethnic region, it is hard to know how seriously to take reports of al Qaeda activity. "When we receive information from people on the street, they know what the buzzwords are to get U.S. soldiers' attention. They know 'al Qaeda,' they know 'Saddam Fedayeen,' " the officer said.
Such complications have led officers working here to "raise the threshold for sourcing," Caraccilo said. But today, Caraccilo decided the new information seemed solid and potentially important.
A Kurdish informant working with local police said an Iraqi named Mohamed Ali Ramadan had been trying to recruit him for a cell of Ansar al-Islam and had already recruited up to 150 other Kirkuk residents. This morning the informant called to say Ramadan had shown up at a house in his neighborhood.
Caraccilo decided to move, fast. He set the operation time for 2 p.m. and predicted, "It'll be over in about five minutes."
Capt. Marty Richards huddled with two other officers to plan the raid, plotting an approach on an eight-foot-high satellite photo of Kirkuk taped to the wall of their briefing room. At 12:40 p.m. came the call: "Mount up!"
As officers quickly piled into two Humvees and an armored personnel carrier, Caraccilo jumped into a white SUV and rumbled off into the city center.
The vehicles gathered at the former Baath Party headquarters in southeastern Kirkuk, which now houses U.S. soldiers. As they set out from there, Caraccilo, now ensconced in one of the lead Humvees, called to Maj. Andrew Rohling in the back seat: "This guy's armed. I don't know what his reaction's going to be. I just want to go through the documents. We need to look for a list [of recruits]. If he's been recruiting, there's got to be a list."
Two helicopters appeared on the horizon, circling toward the house. The pilots radioed to confirm that Ramadan's car, a white Land Cruiser from the nearby city of Sulaymaniyah, was parked there. A half-dozen trucks and jeeps with about 100 soldiers in full body armor fell in behind the lead Humvees. It was 1:40 p.m.
"Scared?" Caraccilo shouted at his troops. They say he always tells them they have to be scared, to stay on their toes. Soldiers in the next jeep gave him the thumbs up: Scared. Caraccilo's driver, Spec. David Tanaka, 22, nodded. "I'm always scared," he said.
They screeched to a halt at the targeted house. A plan had been laid to blast open the front gate, but troops found it unlocked. A man stood in the garden, wondering what the noise was about. The soldiers pulled him into the alley and cuffed him with plastic bands. He turned out to be Kamil Raouf Mohamed, occupant of the house and another suspect.
The troops quickly entered the house and apprehended someone who matched Mohamed Ali Ramadan's description, a short man with a beard and one drooping eye. They cuffed him, too, and made him crouch against an outer wall.
Women and children in the home erupted in panic and hysteria. Mohamed's elderly mother ran into the alley, shrieked and lay on the ground as if in a seizure. Two soldiers carried her back into the house as she continued moaning. Five children, all of whom appeared to be younger than 6 or 7, cowered behind their mothers in the garden. A baby slept through the entire operation on a rug in a front room.
"Put all the women and children in one room!" Rohling ordered.
The soldiers had already begun to tear through the house, searching for evidence. They threw clothes on the floor, upended slats supporting a mattress.
Fahima Hamid, Mohamed's wife, was angry. "You are not Muslim. Why are you doing this to us? We didn't do anything," she hissed in Kurdish.
An Army intelligence officer, along with an Arabic-Kurdish-English translator and a Kirkuk policeman, found a handgun and an assault rifle in the oven -- neither weapon is uncommon or illegal here. Then, in a children's notebook, they found an empty pack of cigarettes with a matchbox inside. In the matchbox was a detonator for an explosive device.
The soldiers also found tiny address books and scrutinized them for clues, but no list of recruits turned up.
Capt. Mike Adamski, an intelligence officer charged with sorting out the documents, said a notebook he found in Mohamed's pocket appeared to contain listings for "a lot of political offices in Iran or near the border. Our initial assessment is this looks like a lot of Iranian phone numbers."
The suspects remained crouched in the garden and the alley, bidden not to talk. But Fahima Hamid claimed to know nothing of her husband's work or his visiting friend. "My husband was a pesh merga," she said, referring to the Kurdish fighters. "He's a day laborer."
Told that the Army believed her husband had ties to al Qaeda, she wailed: "Noooo, no. Al Qaeda is finished. Ansar al-Islam is finished too."
It was 2:45 p.m. "Rolling!" shouted Rohling. The Humvees set off with the suspects.
Caraccilo said he was satisfied; the tip panned out, two men were in custody, no one was hurt.
"If someone tells us to go out and get a couple of guys, like this, it's a success," he said. "Whether or not they turn out to be Osama bin Laden or terrorists, it's not our job to know."
He turned to Rohling in the back seat: "By the way, happy Father's Day."

FBI: Cell phones rigged to set off bombs

WASHINGTON (AP) - Investigators looking into the recent terrorist bombing in Saudi Arabia found cell phones rigged to detonate explosives by remote control, the FBI said Wednesday, urging U.S. law enforcement officials to be on the lookout for similar devices.

The modified cell phones turned up during searches following the May 12 bombing in Riyadh that killed 35 people, including nine Americans, according to a weekly FBI bulletin to 18,000 state and local law enforcement agencies.

Although the FBI said it has no information indicating any of the tens of millions of existing cell phones would be used by terrorists in the United States, the bulletin urged local officials to take precautions if a suspected device is found.

For instance, officers should "immediately evacuate the area to a minimum distance of 300 yards. Radios, cellular telephones and pagers should not be used within 50 feet of the suspected device," the bulletin said.

Terrorists also have used pagers and radio systems to detonate bombs by remote control, the FBI said.

The bulletin did not say whether cell phones were used in the Saudi bombings, nor were there other details about the searches that uncovered the suspicious phones. Saudi officials, who blame al-Qaeda for the attack, said last week they had identified 12 of the attackers and had 25 people in custody in the case.

A cell phone was used in the July 2002 bombing at a cafeteria at Hebrew University in Jerusalem that killed seven people, including five Americans. The bomb, filled with nails and metal, was hidden in a bag left on a table in the crowded room and was detonated by a call from a cell phone.

Late last year French police found explosives systems meant to be detonated with cell phones during a series of raids around Paris that dismantled a terror group with ties to al-Qaeda and rebels in Chechnya.

Experts say the cell phone provides the advantage of allowing the bomber to be far away from the explosion. Timing devices such as windup alarm clocks or radio transmitters more frequently used in improvised pipe bombs usually require the perpetrator to be closer.

The FBI bulletin included details of how a cell phone can become part of a deadly bomb. It requires use of a battery, a switch, an initiation device such as an electric match or a light bulb, conducting wires and explosives. The phone itself is not a bomb.

When the phone receives an incoming call, "the electrical power from the telephone's ringer or vibrator activates the bomb's circuitry" causing an explosion.

"Law enforcement officers without specialized explosives training should never attempt to remove or disable a suspected device," the bulletin warned.

Greg Baur, chief of the International Association of Bomb Technicians and Investigators, said use of cell phones requires expertise to program the phones and handle tiny components. He did not know of a domestic bombing case involving use of a cell phone.

"You'd have to have a lot of technological ability," said Baur, former commander of the Milwaukee police bomb squad. "It takes a certain amount of training, a certain amount of electronic knowledge."

Landline phones have been used in years past to set off smaller explosions, FBI officials say. One technique was to rig the phone so it ignited gasoline-soaked material when it rang. In many of those cases, the aim was to collect insurance money when a building burned.

U.S. Report: al Qaeda Terrorism Attempt Likely in Next Two Years

A U.S. report submitted to the United Nations Security Council on 17 April, but just publicly released on 9 June, said that there is a "high probability" that al Qaeda will attempt a chemical, biological, radiological or nuclear (CBRN) attack in the next two years. Despite advances made to dismantle the organization, the report indicated that "al Qaeda maintains the ability to inflict significant casualties in the United States with little or no warning," CBSNews.com reported. "Al Qaeda will continue to favor spectacular attacks, but also may seek softer targets of opportunity, such as banks, shopping malls, supermarkets, and places of recreation and entertainment," the report stated. It further concluded that is likely the terrorist organization will continue "its efforts to acquire and develop" weapons of mass destruction.

ANALYSIS: The report said, "Identifying and neutralizing these sleeper cells remain our most serious intelligence and law enforcement challenge." While it indicated that the U.S. is conducting "hundreds" of investigations into people and organizations suspected of having ties to al Qaeda, especially on the east and west coasts and in the southwestern U.S., it also suggested that despite these efforts, "the al Qaeda network will remain for the foreseeable future the most immediate and serious terrorism threat facing the United States."

U.S. Sees Likely Al Qaeda WMD Attack Within 2 Years
Mon June 09, 2003 03:31 PM ET

UNITED NATIONS (Reuters) - The United States sees a high probability the clandestine al Qaeda network will try to launch a chemical, biological or nuclear attack within two years, the U.S. government said in a report made public on Monday.

"Al Qaeda will continue to favor spectacular attacks but also may seek softer targets of opportunity such as banks, shopping malls, supermarkets and places of recreation and entertainment," the United States told the United Nations in the report.

"Al Qaeda will continue its efforts to acquire and develop biological, chemical, radiological and nuclear (CBRN) weapons. We judge that there is a high probability that al Qaeda will attempt an attack using a CBRN weapon within the next two years," said the report.

The report, prepared before last month's triple suicide bombings in Saudi Arabia which killed 35 people, did not say whether it thought such an attack would take place inside the United States or elsewhere.

Dated April 17 but just released by the world body, the report was prepared in response to a U.N. Security Council resolution requiring the 191 U.N. member-nations to crack down on al Qaeda -- by, for example, freezing its assets and tracking its agents -- for its role in Afghanistan leading up to the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks.

The group led by Osama bin Laden is blamed by Washington for the suicide hijack attacks, which killed thousands in New York, Washington and Pennsylvania.

Washington said al Qaeda remained the "top concern" of U.S. law enforcement authorities.

There were hundreds of ongoing counter-terrorism investigations in the United States directly associated with the group, most of them on the East and West coasts and in the U.S. Southwest, it said.

But the greatest threat to U.S. security was possible "sleeper cells" that have not been identified or detected, it said. "Identifying and neutralizing these sleeper cells remains our most serious intelligence and law enforcement challenge," the report said.

June 9, 2003
Captives Deny Qaeda Worked With Baghdad
By JAMES RISEN

WASHINGTON, June 8 - Two of the highest-ranking leaders of Al Qaeda in American custody have told the C.I.A. in separate interrogations that the terrorist organization did not work jointly with the Iraqi government of Saddam Hussein, according to several intelligence officials.
Abu Zubaydah, a Qaeda planner and recruiter until his capture in March 2002, told his questioners last year that the idea of working with Mr. Hussein's government had been discussed among Qaeda leaders, but that Osama bin Laden had rejected such proposals, according to an official who has read the Central Intelligence Agency's classified report on the interrogation.
In his debriefing, Mr. Zubaydah said Mr. bin Laden had vetoed the idea because he did not want to be beholden to Mr. Hussein, the official said.
Separately, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the Qaeda chief of operations until his capture on March 1 in Pakistan, has also told interrogators that the group did not work with Mr. Hussein, officials said.
The Bush administration has not made these statements public, though it frequently highlighted intelligence reports that supported its assertions of links between Iraq and Al Qaeda as it made its case for war against Iraq.
Since the war ended, and because the administration has yet to uncover evidence of prohibited weapons in Iraq, the quality of American intelligence has come under scrutiny amid contentions that the administration selectively disclosed only those intelligence reports that supported its case for war.
Bill Harlow, a spokesman for the Central Intelligence Agency, declined to comment on what the two Qaeda leaders had told their questioners. A senior intelligence official played down the significance of their debriefings, explaining that everything Qaeda detainees say must be regarded with great skepticism.
Other intelligence and military officials added that evidence of possible links between Mr. Hussein's government and Al Qaeda had been discovered - both before the war and since - and that American forces were searching Iraq for more in Iraq.
Still, no conclusive evidence of joint terrorist operations by Iraq and Al Qaeda has been found, several intelligence officials acknowledged, nor have ties been discovered between Baghdad and the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks on Washington and New York.
Between the time of the attacks and the start of the war in Iraq in March, senior Bush administration officials spoke frequently about intelligence on two fronts - the possibility of links between Iraq and Al Qaeda, and Baghdad's drive to develop prohibited weapons. President Bush described the war against Iraq as part of the larger war on terrorism, and argued that the possibility that Mr. Hussein might hand over illicit weapons to terrorists posed a threat to the United States.
Several officials said Mr. Zubaydah's debriefing report was circulated by the C.I.A. within the American intelligence community last year, but his statements were not included in public discussions by administration officials about the evidence concerning Iraq-Qaeda ties.
Those officials said the statements by Mr. Zubaydah and Mr. Mohammed were examples of the type of intelligence reports that ran counter to the administration's public case.
"I remember reading the Abu Zubaydah debriefing last year, while the administration was talking about all of these other reports, and thinking that they were only putting out what they wanted," one official said.
Spokesmen at the White House, the State Department and the Pentagon declined to comment on why Mr. Zubaydah's debriefing report was not publicly disclosed by the administration last year.
In recent weeks, the director of central intelligence, George J. Tenet, and other officials have defended the information and analysis by the C.I.A. and other intelligence agencies in the months before the war. They said reports were not suppressed, and were properly handled and distributed among the intelligence agencies.
The issue of the public presentation of the evidence is different from whether the intelligence itself was valid, and some officials said they believed that the former might ultimately prove to be more significant, since the Bush administration relied heavily on the release of intelligence reports to build its case, both with the American people and abroad.
"This gets to the serious question of to what extent did they try to align the facts with the conclusions that they wanted," an intelligence official said. "Things pointing in one direction were given a lot of weight, and other things were discounted."

June 2, 2003
Hearing to Affect Government's Ability to Try Terror Suspects in Civilian Courts
By PHILIP SHENON

WASHINGTON, June 1 - The Justice Department's ability to continue prosecuting members of Al Qaeda and other important terrorist suspects in civilian courts is on the line in a landmark appeals court hearing this week in the government's case against Zacarias Moussaoui, Bush administration officials and defense lawyers agree.
The specific question before the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, in Richmond, Va., on Tuesday is whether Mr. Moussaoui, the only person charged in an American court with conspiring in the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, has the right to question captured Qaeda members held overseas whose testimony may aid in his defense.
The Justice Department is arguing that he has no such right and that the government cannot make captured terrorists available for testimony without divulging national security secrets and interrupting the government's effort to interrogate them for information that might pre-empt terrorist attacks.
But twice this year, Judge Leonie M. Brinkema of Federal District Court in Alexandria, Va., has ruled that Mr. Moussaoui's right to seek out trial testimony for his defense overrides the government's claims of national security damage.
And twice, she has ordered the government to make preparations for Mr. Moussaoui, who wants to act as his own trial lawyer, and his court-appointed legal advisers to question Ramzi bin al-Shibh, a coordinator of the 9/11 attacks who was caught last year in Pakistan.
Mr. bin al-Shibh is being held at an undisclosed place outside the United States.
The impact of the ruling by the Fourth Circuit, which is hearing the Justice Department's appeal of the orders by Judge Brinkema, will most likely go far beyond Mr. Moussaoui, because the issue of defense access to testimony from captured terrorists is almost certain to confront prosecutors whenever they try to bring Qaeda members to trial.
Bush administration officials acknowledge that a ruling against the government in the courts would almost certainly prompt the Justice Department to abandon its prosecution of Mr. Moussaoui in a civilian court and turn him over to the Pentagon for a military tribunal. The case could finish up before the Supreme Court.
In a tribunal, Mr. Moussaoui would most likely have far fewer rights to seek out defense testimony from Mr. bin al-Shibh and others and to control how his case was presented to a jury.
The officials say that a decision to abandon a civilian trial would create dismay at the Justice Department, which wants to retain its authority to prosecute terrorists in civilian courts, but that the Pentagon has made it clear that it would never agree to make important Qaeda suspects available for testimony on behalf of Mr. Moussaoui.
"The implications are uncomfortable," a senior administration official said. "If the Justice Department can't prosecute Moussaoui, there's general agreement that we'll need to avoid civilian trials for other suspects like him." The official said that "these cases will become the Pentagon's show."
Alternately, Mr. Moussaoui's court-appointed legal advisers and some outside legal scholars sat a decision against Mr. Moussaoui - barring him from interviewing Mr. bin al-Shibh and others - would be a serious blow to his case and create troubling limitations on the right of other types of criminal defendants to seek out testimony or evidence that might prove their innocence.
"I will go into the courthouse with a sense that a lot is riding on this," said Frank W. Dunham Jr., the federal public defender in eastern Virginia, who will help argue the appeal in Richmond on behalf of Mr. Moussaoui.
"If I'm not at the top of my game," he said, "I think I could do some serious harm to the Bill of Rights."
The issues, Mr. Dunham said, "involve the right to a fair trial, the right to present a defense, the right to call witnesses in your own behalf, the right to force the government to produce evidence it has that is favorable to the defense - all of those things are on the table."
There appears to be no consensus among lawyers who watch the Fourth Circuit over how it will rule.
While the Fourth Circuit is perhaps the nation's most conservative appeals court and is generally sympathetic to the government's national security arguments, criminal law specialists say that Mr. Moussaoui is supported by long, detailed precedent in arguing that he is entitled to any testimony or evidence that may help exonerate him.
"This is a very difficult balancing act," said Sean D. Murphy, a former State Department lawyer who is now an associate professor of law at George Washington University.
"The Fourth Circuit has been very supportive of the Bush administration's initiatives in prosecuting the war on terrorism," he said. "At the same time, it has drawn a line and made clear that it will not simply defer to what the government wants."
The United States attorney's office in Alexandria, Va., which is prosecuting the case, had no comment on the pending appeals court case apart from its public court filings.
But Andrew G. McBride, a former member of the office who remains in contact with prosecutors there, said his former colleagues were eager to hold on to the Moussaoui case and to prove that the civilian court system was the appropriate place to bring terrorists to justice.
Mr. McBride said he believed the Justice Department had a strong case in arguing that because Mr. bin al-Shibh and other captured Qaeda leaders were being held by the government as enemy combatants outside American borders, the government had no responsibility to make them available to Mr. Moussaoui.
"It's an open issue, but I think there is case law that can be read to be supportive of the government," he said. "I think the prosecutors have handled this case well."
The appeals court showdown is the latest twist in the tortured, 17-month prosecution of Mr. Moussaoui, a confessed Qaeda member who has repeatedly expressed his loyalty to Osama bin Laden, even as he has insisted that he had nothing to do with the 9/11 attacks.
He has been in government custody since August 2001, when he was arrested on immigration charges in Minnesota after arousing the suspicion of a local flight school. He was indicted in December of that year on charges of conspiring to destroy aircraft and commit terrorism, which make him eligible for the death penalty.
As the case has gone on, his handwritten court filings have grown more inflammatory, many of them taunting and ridiculing Judge Brinkema and his court-appointed legal advisers, whom he has repeatedly tried to fire.
Although Mr. Moussaoui has appeared to relish the opportunity at public court hearings to denounce the American government and voice his support for Al Qaeda, he has passed up the chance to appear before the Fourth Circuit on Tuesday, a decision that will leave the arguments in the hands of the court-appointed defense team that he says he reviles.

Cover Story 6/2/03
Playing Offense
The inside story of how U.S. terrorist hunters are going after al Qaeda

By David E. Kaplan
"After 9/11, the gloves come off."

COFER BLACK, former director, CIA Counterterrorism Center

And the brass knuckles came on. America's frontline agents in the war on terror have hacked into foreign banks, used secret prisons overseas, and spent over $20 million bankrolling friendly Muslim intelligence services. They have assassinated al Qaeda leaders, spirited prisoners to nations with brutal human-rights records, and amassed files equal to a thousand encyclopedias.

But the war is far from over. Last week, Osama bin Laden's top deputy exhorted the faithful to strike at western embassies and businesses. The injunction, from Ayman al-Zawahiri, came on the heels of bombings in Morocco and Saudi Arabia and caused the United States to close diplomatic posts overseas and increase the homeland security warning level from yellow to orange. Al Qaeda, one FBI veteran explained, "has one more 9/11 in them."

With all the headlines about the latest attacks and warnings, however, it is easy to miss the amount of damage America's terrorist hunters have inflicted on bin Laden's ragtag army. U.S. News has retraced the war on terror, starting in the very first weeks after 9/11, to examine in detail how Washington and its allies launched an unprecedented drive, led by the Central Intelligence Agency, to disrupt and destroy bin Laden's operation. Interviews were conducted with over three dozen past and current counterterrorism officials in a half-dozen countries; the magazine also reviewed thousands of pages of court records and analytical reports.

The story--part detective yarn, part spy tale--is one of unsung heroes. It is a story of nameless CIA analysts who matched tortured renditions of Arabic names with cellphone numbers around the globe, of Pakistani soldiers killed while smashing down doors of al Qaeda, of Jordanian interrogators who wore down some of bin Laden's craftiest killers. Much of this has not been told before. A windfall of intelligence has led to a newer, more profound understanding of bin Laden's secret network, intelligence officials say. They have built up dossiers on his followers from a scant few hundred before 9/11 to over 3,000 today. They have identified the core group's sworn membership, now thought to number only 180 true believers. And bin Laden's personal fortune, investigators say, is all but gone.

There's more. The investigators have unearthed a secret history of al Qaeda, discovering documents in bin Laden's own hand, along with records identifying donors to the terrorist group. They have forced captured operatives to help target their comrades--even listening in as a terrorist made a phone call that led to the assassination of a top al Qaeda leader.

On the run. Al Qaeda's wounds run deep. Over half of its key operational leaders are out of action, officials tell U.S. News. Its top leaders are increasingly isolated and on the run. Al Qaeda's Afghan sanctuary is largely gone. Its military commander is dead. Its chief of operations sits in prison, as do some 3,000 associates around the world. In the field, every attempt at communication now puts operatives at risk. The organization's once bountiful finances, meanwhile, have become precarious. One recent intercept revealed a terrorist pleading for $80, sources say.

If the global war on terror has a nerve center, it is the CIA's Counterterrorism Center. At first glance, the CTC looks unremarkable, packed with the cubicles, gray desks, and desktop PCs that make up just about any government office in Washington. A hint that its work might be somewhat out of the ordinary is offered by signposts that mark the corridors. One well-trodden intersection lies at the crossroads of Bin Laden Lane and Saddam Street.

The 9/11 attacks severely shook the CTC--staffed, at the time, by some 600 case officers, analysts, and support personnel. "There was real shock," remembers one official. "Our sole job was to stop things like this." Cofer Black had taken the top CTC job two years before 9/11. A near-legendary figure around the CIA, he had spent 26 years in the agency's covert operations division. But as he stared at the expressions on his staff's faces, he was struck by a look he'd seen only overseas. They reminded him of peering into the eyes of Israeli intelligence officials--how haunted and driven they were. "You appreciate the gravity of your situation when your own people are in the kill box," he says. Black knew al Qaeda well. He had chased Osama bin Laden ever since the Saudi exile tried to kill him in Sudan a decade earlier. Black had returned the favor, drafting CIA plans to assassinate bin Laden long before 9/11--plans that, on the order of higher-ups, sat on the shelf.

All that changed after 9/11. Within days, Black's team came up with its answer to al Qaeda. They called it the Worldwide Attack Matrix. It was an operational war plan, a no-holds-barred leap back to the agency's heyday of covert action. As detailed in Bob Woodward's book Bush at War, the Matrix called for a worldwide campaign to root out its cells in 80 countries. Intelligence officials confirmed to U.S. News the dramatic scope of the Matrix and related proposals. The new plans authorized the use of deadly force, break-ins, and psychological warfare. They allowed the CIA to pour millions of dollars into friendly Arab intelligence services and permitted the once gun-shy agency to work with any government--no matter how unsavory--as long as it got results. On September 17, six days after the attack, President Bush signed an executive order approving virtually everything the CIA had asked for.

Job 1 was destroying the terrorists' Afghan sanctuary. "Nothing emboldened al Qaeda more than us not going after them," says Michael Rolince, who ran the FBI's international terrorism section during 9/11. "I sat through hundreds of meetings at which DOD [the Department of Defense] just listened. The people who fought wars had no role in the war on terror." That was about to change.

"Like the Nazis." The war in Afghanistan caught al Qaeda's leaders off guard. Bin Laden's top people were convinced the United States would respond to 9/11 with merely a volley of cruise missiles, interrogations later showed. By late 2001, the U.S.-led assault had taken out al Qaeda's camps and headquarters, killed hundreds of its followers, and driven the Taliban from power. So rapid was the advance that bin Laden's operatives left behind a motherlode of intelligence--address books, videos, computers, and more. Nearly 100 places yielded valuable intelligence, from caves to training centers. Among the key finds: rosters of trainees at al Qaeda facilities, which gave the CIA a handle on the tens of thousands of jihadists who had passed through some 50 camps across Afghanistan." They were like the Nazis," says an FBI terror expert. "They were meticulous record keepers."

One of the richest finds came in November, after a CIA Predator--a remote-controlled drone-tracked dozens of the enemy to a hotel outside Kabul. A U.S. airstrike blew the building apart, killing close to 100, including Mohammed Atef, al Qaeda's longtime military commander and a key planner of the 9/11 and U.S. Embassy attacks in Africa. Investigators also found in the rubble scores of documents and videotapes that would spark alerts in a half-dozen countries. The videos featured five would-be martyrs railing against "infidels" and vowing to die in suicide attacks. Analysts soon recognized one of them: 30-year-old Ramzi Binalshibh, a glib young Yemeni whose hopes to join the 9/11 hijackers were thwarted by visa problems. Binalshibh was nabbed in Pakistan months later. But another--Khaled Jehani--surfaced only last month in Saudi Arabia, blamed as the mastermind of the suicide car bombings in Riyadh.

From the rubble came another video, one revealing assassination plots against leaders at an upcoming Persian Gulf summit. U.S. officials pulled faces off the tape of some 45 al Qaeda operatives. Also in the ruins: a German passport in the name of one Mohammed Haydar Zammar, a fugitive thought to have recruited the Hamburg, Germany, cell members behind 9/11. Investigators soon caught up to Zammar in Morocco. But perhaps the biggest find was yet another video--a homemade, 20-minute surveillance tape of Singapore. The tape helped officials there thwart an extraordinary series of plots by Jamaat Islamiya--al Qaeda's key ally in Southeast Asia. The militants hoped to spark a holy war by bombing U.S. military sites and businesses, diplomatic posts, and the city's subway and water supply.

The intelligence "take" from the Kabul hotel and other sites was quickly crated up and shipped to the CTC for a closer look. Once considered a backwater at the CIA, the CTC now stood at the heart of the biggest surge of covert action since the Cold War. Cofer Black found himself overseeing secret operations, paramilitary units, propaganda efforts, and more. In the weeks after 9/11, the CTC nearly doubled in size to over 1,100 people, including FBI agents, military officers, and CIA operatives. Before 9/11, the CTC had focused on a dozen different terrorist groups; it now restructured to zero in almost exclusively on al Qaeda. New teams concentrated on finances, leadership, collection of intelligence, and work with foreign governments. Analysts sorted through reams of field reports, satellite photos, and electronic intercepts. Link-analysis printouts, some as big as bedsheets, lined the walls of cubicles, as researchers charted al Qaeda's far-flung contacts. "There are subnetworks of subnetworks," says a top intelligence official. "Thank God we've got giant printers."

By late November, the amount of intelligence pouring in was overwhelming, and CTC staffers understood why. For years, their efforts at fighting terror had vied with a dozen other priorities of U.S. foreign policy. But the message from Washington now was clear. "No nation can be neutral in this conflict," declared President Bush. "You're either with us or you're against us." The results were immediate. "Before 9/11, the cooperation was halfhearted," recalls Richard Clarke, the top counterterrorism official at the National Security Council at the time of the attack. "But now everyone knew the president had a blank check to do whatever he wanted." From the Indian government came intercepts of al Qaeda-tied militants in Kashmir; from Italy, wiretapped conversations of Islamic radicals in Milan; from Sudan, long-awaited files on bin Laden operatives once headquartered in Khartoum. Much to the delight of old pros at the CIA, intelligence arrived even from old foes, among them Libya and Syria.

Bits and pieces. Each day, the CTC took in some 2,500 cables from CIA stations overseas; each week, some 17,000 new bits of intelligence arrived. And that didn't count the huge hauls from Afghanistan. One veteran case officer said the amounts were measured "literally in terabytes"--a terabyte is roughly equal to a thousand bound editions of the Encyclopedia Britannica. The CTC had become the world's single largest collector and coordinator for intelligence on terrorism. So large is the volume of material collected, sources tell U.S. News, that even today, substantial amounts remain unexamined.

By March 2002, the intelligence windfall revealed how little U.S. intelligence had understood about al Qaeda. "There were tremendous gaps in our understanding of al Qaeda's structure, its chain of command, its operational network," says Roger Cressey, director for transnational threats at the National Security Council at the time of 9/11. "Think of it as a 1,000-piece jigsaw in which we had maybe 200 pieces. After 9/11, the pieces came fast and furious."

America's best analysts were troubled as they surveyed the new intelligence. "It was even worse than we thought," says Black, who was struck by Afghan reports of dead al Qaeda fighters with blond hair and blue eyes--Chechens--as well as Uzbeks, Indonesians, and Chinese. "They had internationalized themselves to a far greater degree," he says, "and it was all networked really well."

The body kills, the seized computers and correspondence, combined with prisoner interrogations and other intelligence, offered a fairly complete portrait of bin Laden's secretive organization. Analysts began to grasp how al Qaeda actually operated, from its finances to its key personnel. Before 9/11, U.S. intelligence had files on only a few hundred al Qaeda-trained Islamists. But by March, the number had ballooned to 3,000 and was growing daily.

As their knowledge increased, analysts learned to differentiate among the varied bands of jihadists. As one counterterrorism veteran explained, there are, in effect, two al Qaedas: One is al Qaeda the ideology, which fuels a sprawling network of radical Islamists who draw inspiration from bin Laden but are not his direct disciples. Within that network are what analysts have called al Qaeda's franchises--allied radical groups from Uzbekistan to Indonesia who share bin Laden's dream of a pan-Islamist world. But there is also al Qaeda the organization--a finite, disciplined, Mafia-like grouping with its own rules, finances, and "made" members. Although tens of thousands went through its training camps, very few in fact joined the group. "Al Qaeda is an elite organization that takes very few members," exp